City, we rise; United, we fall…Lessons from Manchester 2011-12

The most watched football league in the world, Barclays English Premier League, undoubtedly had an epic finale to its 2011-12 season. The winner of the year-long battle for glory was decided and sealed in less than five minutes.

While at the Stadium of Light, Sunderland FC’s home ground, Manchester United reigned supreme and won with a goal’s margin, Manchester City produced a game at Etihad Stadium, its home ground, that can only be described as phenomenal. The title holder was to be decided between the two Manchester teams, with City needing a win at home to surpass United, who played away to Sunderland.

Towards the end of the ninety minutes, it looked like United were destined to lift the trophy for the twentieth time. Sir Alex Ferguson, United’s manager for over quarter of a century, looked confident of having done just enough to win both their final game and the title. While Ferguson just waited for the final confirmation of his success through the referee’s final whistle, Roberto Mancini, Manchester City’s manager, hoped for a miracle at Etihad.

As if He heard his prayers, The Almighty granted City that opportunity to prove to the world the existence of a miracle. Edin Dzeko, the Bosnian striker who moved to Manchester City in Jan 2011, emerged as that miracle in the 92nd minute of the 5-minute stoppage time.

A corner kick converted into a brilliant header by Dzeko put some hope into the Citizens. The long-awaited equaliser had finally come. There was still work to be done, however. City needed to win the match to etch their name on the trophy. As would be expected, with just a couple of minutes left on the clock, City attacked incessantly and out of the blue, Sergio Aguero, after the slightest of touches to get a clean shot, created history for City. City, the tortoise in the race, proved their worth at Etihad with late goals, driving Citizens crazy.

On the other side of the battle for the title, United had already finished their match and were awaiting news from City. But in a tragic quirk of fate that rendered him speechless, Ferguson could only wonder what had hit him when he heard the score and success of City at Etihad. He would have almost certainly felt those ‘so-close-yet-so-far’ emotions that give a sense of seeing the finish line of a marathon yet being unable to reach there first. Darkness had suddenly befallen the Stadium of Light, not for Sunderland, who were not in contention for the title, but for Manchester United, who had their victory snatched away by a whisker. United had already taken the shuttle to seventh heaven but were brought back. Manchester had changed colours – from glazing red to sky blue in less than five minutes.

Sorry, the image could not be loaded at this moment


Aguero emerged as the saviour for City, bringing league glory back after forty-four long years of patience. Jubilant City fans had moments of nostalgia and at least a half of the city had reason to celebrate while the other half tried to figure out what had just happened.

As all this unfolded and the excitement subsided, I analysed the season in my own perspective and looked at what I could learn. Towards the end of the season, April and May in particular, I noticed some aspects that struck out as crucial to one’s learning.

1. One gets what one deserves. Manchester City truly deserved the title. City performed when it mattered the most, stuck to their guns and did not choke under pressure. Big spenders City have picked up talent from all over the globe and it has proved crucial when it mattered. Dzeko’s arrival in January 2011 and Aguero’s in July 2011 show that it is important to have the right talent, in addition to a strong vision, to achieve a goal, literally and figuratively.

2. How to lose the lead when it’s almost in your bag: Manchester United, who had almost sealed the title around April, became complacent and paid a huge price. Despite an eight-point lead till April, United threw it all away in spectacular fashion to hurt them when they were supposed to be cruising to victory. The draw with Everton was one of the most damage-inflicting results of the season.

Sorry, the image could not be loaded at this time


A two goal lead was squandered away in the final few minutes of the game at Old Trafford, United’s home ground, due to an appalling defensive display. The Red Devils, known for their fluid counter-attacking play, could not even get enough shots on target against derby rivals City in the final few games of the season. Such lacklustre performance only added to City’s chase and United’ downfall from a pedestal of vantage.

3. Temperament of the leadership needs to carry the team till the end. Sir Alex Ferguson may arguably be one of the best managers in the history of English football, but he failed this season to take his team home across the finish line. His squad selection in crucial games has received much criticism, his verbal spat with Mancini in the so-called title-decider came under fire, and even his renowned strategies failed, and, at times, even boomeranged. Ferguson, who referred to City as “Noisy Neighbours”, was silenced by the noise at the end of the season.

Sorry, the image could not be loaded at this time


4. There is a misconception that money buys victories. I have heard numerous United fans lament that deep-pocketed City won only because they were able to buy the world’s best players. I, frankly, find this notion foolish because there is no correlation between deep pockets and wins. Secondly, United also has deep pockets and the management at United has always been supportive of the decisions taken by Ferguson and his team.

What matters is what one does with all the resources at one’s disposal. Had Ferguson snapped up a couple of star players, which were rumoured to be transferred, we could have seen an entirely different end to the season, who knows !!!

Barcelona and Real Madrid, Spanish giants in all respects, have used their power to attract players since time immemorial. But I’ve not seen as many people complain about these clubs as against City.

This is not to say that money is not a factor at all. Financial backing by owners and directors does obviously matter, but what matters more than that is the ability to invest smartly on players who can produce results. City played that hand well and were rewarded for it.

5. Competition can arise out of nowhere. After a long time, the title race was fought only between the two Manchester clubs. The London-based clubs had a torrid time this season. Champions League finalists Chelsea finished sixth, third placed Arsenal were 19 points behind the two Manchesters and Liverpool, well, let’s not even go there…

Sorry, the image could not be loaded at this time

The might of the Red Devils as the more prominent team from Manchester has been challenged. London clubs will face a Herculean task next year when they try to assert their stand on the league as they face not one, but two immensely competitive teams from Manchester. Expect some big names to fly to London next season, not necessarily for the Olympics, though.

Quite a lot to learn from football, eh? What are your views? Which team do you support? What was your reading of this season? Drop me a line and let me know…


9 thoughts on “City, we rise; United, we fall…Lessons from Manchester 2011-12

  1. hey…detailing is good…why no mention about Yaya Toure…he deserves a mention…coz the crunch games as u said…he was ‘the’ performer…
    but call me a critic…the drama that was created by QPR when they scored those two goals…the red side was enjoying like hell…
    one more piece of history…the last time ‘noisy neighbours’ won the league, 44 years ago, they had won it on the last day…red devils had lost on that day and city had won…and guess what…who had beaten the red devils and where…it was SUNDERLAND at the STADIUM OF LIGHT…who says history doesnot repeat itself…

    but a nice read for a neutral…informative…now eagerly awaiting the night in MUNICH – ALLIANZ ARENA…


    • Hey buddy first of all thanks for stopping by. Appreciate your effort to detail out events and points.
      Btw, as I mentioned, I have cited only those two players because they scored in the final. Yaya Toure was certainly one of the key performers for City but not a scorer in the final match. I was primarily focused on only the final match and hence no mention in particular. However, I have acknowledged that I missed out (deliberately) some key players.
      Yep, QPR almost Choked the Chokers. In fact, City handed them the first goal on a platter. 🙂
      Wow that is an interesting fact !!! United and City in title contention 44 years ago in a similar manner !!! That too must have been quite a sight !!!
      Yep, I side with the Germans though at the Allianz Arena.
      Nonetheless, thanks again for taking time out to read and reply.


  2. Mancini, in the last couple of years, has spent on transfers more than what Ferguson has in the last 25 years.

    Let this also be pointed out that the last time City picked up the trophy was in 1968. United have been runners up 7 times and winners 11 times (excluding both the 1967-68 title and 2011-12 season) during this period. So, undoubtedly, United has been far more consistent than City ever could have been. Nevertheless, this might be a start but I personally do not see City bagging as many titles as United has. The 2011-12 title was definitely City’s deserved, but you can never say what Fergie might just be planning for the next year.

    This season’s performance by City, although noteworthy, was also shown by clubs like Blackburn Rovers and Leeds United in the earlier years of tthe EPL. Does this mean this was a once in a blue moon spark for City, or can they really keep it up this way? Who’s to say?
    [Blackburn Rovers, Leeds United and now Manchester City all have 3 titles each]


    • Well said Vrushank. I absolutely agree that Mancini, a big spender, has been immensely helped by Sheikh Mansour. But, when it comes to core footballing practices, who and how can you account for a 19-title winning team to let go of an eight-point lead in the final few games of the season? I do not doubt United’s capacity and capability to bounce right back in the next season. However, my concern arises because of the gradually growing complacency in the team.
      Now that City has bagged a thriller, they will go to next season with an immense confidence over not just United, but over the entire league. The rest of the league teams will have to pick their pace up if they are to keep up with City.

      Anyway, glad to have you stop by. 🙂


  3. I agree with your analysis! Manchester City played well and who wouldn’t buy as much talent as they could? Sir Alex needs to let some other teams win for a change lol


    • Yep. SAF needs a metamorphosis, either in the form of a star (perhaps Eden Hazard), or in the form of a couple of young talents. The current United squad barely managed to reach and stay at the top (and finish second), and the next season won’t be so, with Chelsea going to bounce back strong after their boost due to the CL. The first six will be a close fight…


  4. Pingback: The odyssey to the odyssey of camaraderie… | An Odyssey of Camaraderie

  5. Pingback: The odyssey to the odyssey of camaraderie… | The Wordy Nerdy Pedantic

Please honour me with your opinion on this...

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s